Clyde Tombaugh and the Discovery of Pluto

Clyde Tombaugh as a young man looking through a telescope.

Prefer to listen? This story is also available as a podcast episode on Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and most podcast platforms.

It’s late afternoon in western Kansas, 1926. Twenty-year-old Clyde Tombaugh is grinding a glass disk behind his farmhouse. Using abrasive grit and slurry, the young farmer is shaping the glass into a shallow curve that will gather starlight and bring it into focus.

Clyde Tombaugh black and white photo standing by his telescope.
Clyde Tombaugh. Public Domain.

The work stretches from the winter days into spring. He tests, refines, and tests again. When he judges it done, he ships it to Napoleon Carreau, a telescope maker and optician based in Wichita, Kansas as Carreau specializes in silvering optical mirrors. Clyde waits for the verdict. Has he actually made a mirror that will work in a telescope?

When Carreau’s letter finally arrives, the news is not good. The mirror has a poor figure and won’t work well.

But here’s the strange part. The glass isn’t what failed Clyde. It’s his house. Warm air currents distort the precise measurements he needs to test the mirror’s figure.

The fix comes that same fall when the Tombaughs do something every farm needs sooner or later. They dig a root cellar into the earth. It’s cool enough for storage and sturdy enough to outlast a tornado. Clyde talks his father into making it a larger pit so he can work in the earth’s cooler air, where the temperature stays steady.

And it works.

In his new underground world, he makes his first successful mirror, a 7-inch, for his Uncle Lee in the spring of 1927.

The money his uncle sends for that job buys the glass for his next ambition: a 9-inch mirror. For the mount, Clyde scavenges pieces off the farm. To carry the telescope tube, he builds a mount from the heavy cast-iron base of an old cream separator, a crankshaft pulled from his father’s retired 1910 Buick, and a spring from a lawn-mower seat.

Clyde Tombaugh and his homemade 9-inch reflecting telescope.

Through that fall and winter, he works the glass again. By late winter 1928, after weeks of work, he finally achieves the best parabolic curve he’s ever made. He ships the finished glass off to Carreau.

When the silvered mirror arrives in the mail, Clyde finishes his telescope. With it, he can observe the Moon’s craters and test the glass on distant star fields. But his days still belong to the farm. And no one—least of all Clyde—has any idea yet what this instrument will mean for him.

Hailstorm

By the early summer of 1928, the farm has never looked better. Acres of oats stand shoulder-high behind the house, planted almost as an afterthought. The wheat around it runs tall and green, and on June 20th, the late morning settles into that thick, windless heat that hangs over Kansas this time of year.

Color photo of a hailstorm over a farm field.
Storm developing over a farm by Péter Kövesi.

Then, out of the northwest, the cloud tops rise fast. The base turns gray, then a deep, blue-green. That color means ice is riding somewhere inside, joined by thunder rolling off the plains.

Across the yard, the wind picks up speed. Muron, his father, shouts for the horses. Clyde is right behind him. The whole family drops into a drill they’ve run a dozen times before. Horses in. Cows penned. Doors latched.

Then the first hailstone hits the roof. Then another—and another. The knocking becomes a clattering wall as the hail bounces off the porch boards and buries itself in the yard.

Then, as fast as it came, the thunderstorm moves on.

Clyde surveys the ruined fields after his father turns back toward the house. Any hope of paying for college is beaten flat into the mud. And then the thought, building over time, settles in:

“Farming is not for me. The first chance I have of getting out of it, I’m going.”

Mars, Jupiter, and Fate

Summer passes into autumn that year of 1928, and Clyde’s days are spent running a neighbor’s combine to earn back a fraction of what the storm destroyed. But by night, he turns his 9-inch reflector upward. He spends hours at the eyepiece, sketching Jupiter’s detailed storm bands and Mars’s crawling maria.

The seasons turn again, and now the wheat stubble gives way to frost. He’s still out there, in the freezing cold, under the clear sky of the plains.

By December, he has a stack of these drawings—enough, he decides, to send somewhere that might offer expert advice on his work. He slides them into an envelope addressed to the Lowell Observatory in Flagstaff, Arizona. He isn’t asking for a job. He has no university degree to lean on. The letter drops into the mailbag, and the waiting begins.

Clyde Tombaugh’s drawings.

Just days later, a letter arrives from Wichita. It’s from Napoleon Carreau, the optician who silvered his mirrors. Carreau has not forgotten the young farmer. Business is good, he writes, and he asks Clyde if he’d be interested in taking a job at his shop.

It would mean a steady paycheck and a ticket off the farm.

Before Clyde can consider the deal, another envelope arrives—this one postmarked Flagstaff.

It is from Dr. V. M. Slipher, the director of the Lowell Observatory. Slipher doesn’t critique the sketches. Instead, his letter includes a volley of pointed questions: What is your schooling? What are your instruments? And, strangely: Are you in good physical health?

Clyde writes back, answering every question. Then another letter from Slipher arrives. The observatory, Slipher explains, is preparing a new photographic telescope. The work will demand long hours in an unheated dome through the dead of winter. He asks if Clyde would be willing to travel to Arizona to operate it on a ninety-day trial basis.

There, in his hands, Clyde holds two tickets out of the farm fields. He can go east to Wichita and spend his life building instruments for others. Or he can go west to Flagstaff and look through a professional telescope himself.

It is no choice at all. What amateur astronomer could resist the pull of a professional observatory?

He packs his suitcase and buys a one-way fare to Flagstaff. He has just enough cash to get him there sight unseen. Then reality hits: he has no money for a return trip if he fails.

On January 14, 1929, his father drives him thirty miles to the depot in Larned, Kansas. The parting words are a little gruff, but loving: “Clyde, make yourself useful, and beware of easy women.”

Clyde boards the train, and with a heavy jolt, it inches from the station. He’s now on his way toward the setting sun and the icy domes of Mars Hill at Lowell Observatory.

Arriving in Flagstaff

The train pulls into Flagstaff a little after one o’clock. Clyde steps down onto the platform as the conductor hands him his baggage. “Quite a trunk you have there,” he says. “What do you have in it?”

“Books,” Clyde says.

Inside the depot, a gray-haired man steps forward before Clyde can even ask. “Are you Mr. Tombaugh?”

“Yes.”

“Glad to see you arrived safely. I’m Dr. Slipher.”

Outside, snow sits heavy on the road.

Slipher’s car takes the grade in low gear as it climbs Mars Hill. Partway up a steep pitch, the wheels give up entirely. The car slides backward. Slipher doesn’t say a word. He just backs down to level ground and points the hood at the hill again, taking it with more speed. The second run takes.

At the top, the administration building sits against the pines. Slipher leads him past a woman at a typewriter. It’s Mrs. Fox, the secretary. And up a narrow staircase to a small room. “This is yours. You may want to rest a little.”

Clyde sits down in the single chair, feeling the thin mountain air at seven thousand feet.

Near five that evening, he rides down the mountain with Mrs. Fox to find dinner in town. He’s taking in a new life a world away from everything he has known. After dinner, he starts back up on foot, alone this time, the road climbing away from Flagstaff’s last lit windows. The ponderosa pines close in on both sides, snow banked white beneath them. Above the treeline, the sky is pitch-black, and the stars seem closer than ever before.

This makes me stop for a moment and wonder: I think about Clyde walking up that hill. I’ve driven up that hill myself on a visit to Lowell several years ago. It’s a windy trek—and I can only imagine how it must have felt to walk in the freezing dark.

The next morning, Dr. Slipher sends Clyde out to the new 13-inch photographic telescope. The dome stands open. The tube is hollow and waiting for a lens still traveling by rail from the East. Inside, machinist Stanley Sykes and his son Guy work the equatorial mount, drilling hand-control fittings into the heavy steel polar axis. Finishing the job falls to Clyde.

He also settles into the rest of the work. On afternoons, he leads public tours up the path to the great 24-inch refractor. At night, he returns to the basement to feed the furnace with heavy pine logs, keeping the buildings warm until morning. Between chores, he learns the darkroom. This includes exposing and developing the glass plates. And when the lens finally arrives, he helps align and focus it. Handling farm machinery has prepared him well.

The Hunt for Planet X

On April 6, 1929, the real search begins. Clyde steps into the unheated dome of the 13-inch astrograph and inherits an unfinished obsession.

Black and white photo of the Pluto Dome at Lowell Observatory
Pluto Discovery Astrograph Dome at Lowell Observatory.
Credit: Brian C. Grogan. Public Domain.

Decades earlier, Percival Lowell became convinced that small irregularities in the paths of Uranus and Neptune pointed to a ninth planet still out there. Lowell spent his fortune and his final years chasing the idea, and died in 1916 with the mystery unsolved. Thirteen years later, the task rests on Clyde’s shoulders.

Percival Lowell observing through a telescope.
Percival Lowell observing Venus from the Lowell Observatory in 1914. Public Domain.

The work is long and solitary. Night after night he climbs a wooden stepladder in sub-zero air. He peers through a guiding eyepiece for an hour at a stretch, making tiny corrections to keep a guide star locked on the crosshairs while the telescope gathers faint light onto a 14-by-17-inch glass plate. By the end of June, he has exposed more than a hundred plates, mapping the sky.

Color photo of the Pluto telescope that Tombaugh used to find Pluto.
The historic Pluto Discovery Telescope is a 13-inch astrograph. The glass plates are inserted in the wooden rectangle box at the bottom. Photo: Wayne McGraw

Late that same June, an astronomer from an eastern observatory pays Mars Hill a visit. Dr. Slipher and Clyde walk him out to the dome to show off the new 13-inch telescope and explain the search for Planet X.

As they return to the administration building, the hallway telephone rings for the director. While Slipher steps into his office to answer it, the astronomer leans over to Clyde and says softly:

“Young man, I am afraid you are wasting your time. If there were any more planets to be found, they would have been found long before this.”

Clyde stands his ground, even as doubt hangs heavy in the air.

By January 1930, Clyde returns to his search in the constellation Gemini. On the night of January 21, a howling gale roars up Mars Hill ten minutes into an exposure. The wind shakes the dome. The guide star Delta Geminorum swells into a blurred ball larger than Jupiter. Clyde fights the cold as he finishes his exposures. What he doesn’t know is this exposed plate will soon play a critical role in his discovery.

Clyde Tombaugh’s observation notes from January 21, 1930. Photo: Wayne McGraw

Weeks later, the search moved indoors into a cramped basement room and the blink comparator—a massive cast-iron machine originally brought to Mars Hill years earlier at the urging of senior astronomer Carl Lampland.

Color photo of the blink comparator used by Clyde Tombaugh to discover Pluto.
The blink comparator Clyde Tombaugh used to discover Pluto. Photo: Wayne McGraw

While Lampland and Slipher pursued their own research programs, Clyde spent hours alone at the eyepiece, sifting through millions of stars. Through a single eyepiece, a shutter clicks back and forth several times a second. Stars stay fixed. Anything that has moved—asteroid, comet, or planet—jumps.

Each plate holds hundreds of thousands of stars packed like grains of sand. Clyde studies them a square at a time. What makes the work even tougher is that he has to discard the false alarms: flaws, dust, and swarms of ordinary asteroids that leap across his field of view.

A Shift in the Stars

It is roughly four o’clock on Tuesday, February 18, 1930. He loads the blink comparator with a plate he exposed on January 23 and another he exposed on January 29. He scans the pair taken six nights apart, centered on the star Delta Geminorum in Gemini. In the corner of his eye, something flutters. He stops. He flips the shutter by hand. A dot of light—fifteenth magnitude, barely there—shifts about 3 and a half millimeters. Asteroids move much faster across the plates. This one has shifted only a few millimeters in nearly a week.

Photo of the Pluto Plates showing the movement of Pluto from January 23, 1930 to January 29, 1930.
Side-by-side discovery plates capture Pluto’s subtle shift in position between January 23 and January 29, 1930. Arrow points to Pluto. Credit: Lowell Observatory Archives.

Clyde calculates the motion. It is so slow and so faint it must be sitting billions of miles out, on the frozen edge of the solar system. He pulls a third plate, taken that windy night of January 21. He mounts it. The same tiny dot is there. He sits back in the dim room, alone. For forty-five minutes, no one else on Earth knows what he knows.

Across the hallway, Dr. Carl Lampland sits at his desk, listening to the machine’s familiar clatter. Once he noticed it had stopped for those minutes, he figured something was up. Then Clyde shows up at his office door and asks him to come look.

Lampland peers in, adjusts the focus, watches the dot jump, too. Clyde continues down the hall. Dr. Slipher is at his desk, buried in paperwork. Clyde then announces: “Dr. Slipher, I have found your Planet X.”

Slipher bolts upright. Without a word, he strides down the corridor so fast Clyde has to jog to keep pace. The director presses his eye to the instrument, flips the plates, sees the leap, and turns.

“Don’t tell anyone until we follow it for a few weeks. This could be very hot news.” And then asks Clyde to rephotograph the region.

It’s around six o’clock in the evening by now—and the sky is cloudy. Clyde drives down to town for the mail and dinner, checks the sky again, finds more clouds, and does the only sensible thing a man who has just found a planet can do: he goes to the movies! He watches Gary Cooper in the 1929 film The Virginian. Later he will write that his knees kept shaking during the gun duel.

The March 13th Announcement

For the next month Mars Hill works in secrecy. Night after night the astronomers train the observatory’s telescopes on the object. Dr. Lampland tracks it using the 42-inch reflector. He watches it crawl across the stars. Then, on March 13, 1930, the big announcement goes out to the world. It’s timed to coincide with the seventy-fifth anniversary of Percival Lowell’s birth and the anniversary of William Herschel’s discovery of Uranus.

Back in western Kansas, a newspaper editor telephones the farmhouse in Burdett. Clyde’s father answers.

“Did you know your son discovered a planet? It’s in the news everywhere!” The editor asks.

“No, but I know he was on the trail of one,” Muron replies.

Muron rushes outside to tell his wife.

“Who was that on the phone?” she asks.

“It’s about Clyde.”

“Is something wrong about Clyde?”

“No, Leslie Wallace said that the wires were reporting Clyde had discovered a planet! We must send a telegram and congratulate him.”

Just think of the conversation out at the farmhouse that day!

A Name from the Underworld

Once the announcement reached the world, the next question was obvious: what do you call a newly found planet?

Over a thousand suggestions flooded the Lowell Observatory. Percival Lowell’s widow, Constance, first proposed Zeus, then lobbied to name it Percival, and finally suggested her own name, Constance.

The winning idea came from Oxford, England. Eleven-year-old Venetia Burney, fascinated by classical mythology, suggested Pluto—the Roman god of the underworld —perfectly suited for a dark, frigid realm at the edge of the Sun’s light.

Portrait photo of Venetia Burney who named Pluto.
A studio portrait photograph of Venetia Burney, aged 11. Credit: J. Weston & Sons, Eastbourne. Public Domain.

Her grandfather cabled the idea to astronomers, and the staff at Mars Hill fell in love with it. Beyond the mythological fit, the first two letters—P and L—served as a permanent monogram honoring Percival Lowell himself.

The discovery changed everything. The farm boy who lost his college money to a summer hailstorm received a full scholarship to the University of Kansas and earned the astronomy degrees he once thought were out of reach. He spent the next decade hunting the sky, discovering numerous asteroids, variable stars, star clusters, and galaxies. He went on to track early ballistic rockets at White Sands, taught generations of students at New Mexico State University, and left a legacy as one of the most tenacious observers the world has known.

Clyde Tombaugh died in 1997 at the age of ninety. His journey did not end there.

Years after his passing, astronomers would reclassify Pluto as a dwarf planet. But rather than diminishing his work, it revealed something far grander. Clyde hadn’t just found a lonely oddity on the fringe. Pluto was the first glimpse we had of a vast population of icy worlds that astronomers would eventually recognize as the Kuiper Belt.

Among the Stars He Chased

In 2006, NASA launched the New Horizons spacecraft on a three-billion-mile voyage to photograph the icy world he had found through the eyepiece seventy-six years earlier. Inside the probe rode a small aluminum capsule holding an ounce of his ashes.

Photo of Pluto from New Horizons spacecraft.
New Horizons’ true-color view of Pluto as it approached the minor planet on July 14, 2015. Credit: NASA/Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory/Southwest Research Institute/Alex Parker

Those ashes have now crossed Pluto’s orbit and continue outward toward interstellar space—carrying the boy from Burdett, Kansas, into the stars he spent a lifetime chasing.

Sources and Further Reading

Cruikshank, Dale P., and William Sheehan. Discovering Pluto: Exploration at the Edge of the Solar System. Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 2018.

Hoyt, William Graves. Planets X and Pluto. Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 1980.

Tombaugh, Clyde W., and Patrick Moore. Out of the Darkness: The Planet Pluto. Harrisburg, PA: Stackpole Books, 1980.

Leave a Reply